If you’d like to add a personal touch, consider serving homemade appetizers like stuffed figs, mini meatballs, or these Thanksgiving-inspired finger foods to impress your guests before the feast arrives. Below, we’ve rounded up the best places to order Thanksgiving dinner and catering in NYC for 2024.
Top NYC Restaurants and Markets for Thanksgiving Catering
These restaurants, bakeries, and markets across New York City have you covered, so you can focus on what matters most: enjoying pie, good company, and crashing on the couch by 8 p.m.
1. Citarella
Address: Multiple Locations
Phone: 212-874-0383
Order By: Friday, November 22, no later than 4 p.m., for pick-up or local delivery between November 25–27.
This beloved gourmet market offers an extensive à la carte Thanksgiving menu with options like classic roast turkey, whole filet mignon, and handcrafted stuffing varieties—chestnut, sausage, or wild rice. The sides are just as impressive, featuring dishes like pumpkin mushroom risotto and sweet potatoes with praline. If the choices feel overwhelming, opt for their chef-prepared Thanksgiving feast, which includes all the holiday staples without the stress of deciding.
2. Bklyn Larder
Address: 228 Flatbush Ave., Brooklyn
Phone: 718-783-1250
Order By: Wednesday, November 15, for pick-up or local delivery.
This Brooklyn provisions shop goes all out with a full spread that includes a boneless, brined turkey roll stuffed with sausage. Their sides range from roasted fall squash and mashed potatoes to mac and cheese, vegetarian kale Caesar salad, and creamed kale. Don’t forget their classic holiday pies, and for an extra touch, their cheese platters are always a crowd-pleaser.
3. Houseman
Address: 508 Greenwich St.
Phone: 212-641-0654
Order for pick-up on Wednesday, November 27, before 2 p.m.
This Tribeca gem is a must-visit for food lovers, but you can also enjoy their offerings at home. Their to-go menu includes turkey served two ways: confit legs and sliced breast with Cracklin salad and jus. Pair it with the curry kabocha squash soup and potato-celery root purée to elevate your Thanksgiving spread.
4. Four & Twenty Blackbirds
Address: 439 3rd Ave., Brooklyn
Phone: 718-499-2917
Order By: No specific deadline, but Thanksgiving ordering began on October 15, and inventory is limited.
This cult-favorite pie shop, run by two sisters, is known for perfecting Thanksgiving desserts. Their salted caramel apple, brown-butter pumpkin, and signature salty honey pies are fan favorites. This year, they’ve added a bittersweet chocolate pecan pie to the menu, which is reportedly decadent and absolutely worth trying.
5. Hard Rock Cafe
Address: 1501 Broadway
Phone: 212-343-3355
Order By: Reservations recommended for dining in; no deadline for takeout orders.
Located in Times Square, the Hard Rock Cafe is open 365 days a year, including Thanksgiving. In addition to its regular menu (which features a collaboration with soccer legend Lionel Messi), the restaurant offers a special holiday feast. This includes turkey breast, roasted vegetables, stuffing, sweet potato mash, cranberry sauce, and gravy, topped off with a slice of pumpkin pie. For an added treat, try their cranberry mojito when picking up your meal.
If you found this article about Thanksgiving interesting, please share it. You can also check this article about SCOPE Art Show in our Luster English section